Retro Caramel Chocolate Cake

October 24, 2010

Chocolate Caramel Cake

A sweet and sticky chocolate caramel cake from the rare Nyamutin Farm Cookbook (1973). As promised, I’ve been digging through the archives to bring you some gorgeous vintage recipes from rare sources.

This isn’t caramel flavour as we expect in 2010, with caramel and fleur de sel or dulche de leche being de rigueur these days. Instead, 1960s housewives reached for the golden syrup. And Amen to that I say, for what results is a down-to-earth, unpretentious, uncomplicatedly glorious rich cake that tastes quite similar to a sticky date pudding.

To finish the cake, I went with a simple old-school chocolate icing, and a sprinkling of finely chopped walnuts for a little bit of crunch. This caramel chocolate cake could even be served au naturale, as the flavours in the cake steal the show on their own.

The origins of the Nyamutin Farm Cookbook are quite darling. In the late 1960s, Misses Bernice and Trixie Shaddick assembled a group of ladies in country Western Australia. They would meet at each other’s homes every two months to discuss fundraising ideas over afternoon tea. By offering their cooking and baking prowess at parties, weddings, jumble sales, and bake stalls, they would raise money for charity. Much like a scene lifted from the stunningly rendered retro TV series Mad Men. (Oh the dresses!)

The ladies developed the “Nyamutin Farm Cookbook”, filled it with their favourite personal recipes, and sold it as a fundraiser. Since the book has no glossy photos of the cakes and scant detail in the method, it really made me think about the purpose of each ingredient and the chemistry of baking with each step. Two attempts and one messy kitchen later I got the cake just right, so I’ve fleshed out the original method in more detail for you below. Perhaps one for your next soiree with the ladies…

Caramel Chocolate Cake

Submitted by P. Weatherhead

1.5 cups Plain Flour
1 large Egg
120g Unsalted Butter, room temperature
1 cup Caster Sugar
1 teaspoon Baking Powder
1 teaspoon Bicarb Soda
1 cup Whole Milk, room temperature (microwave to heat)
1 tablespoon Golden Syrup
1 tablespoon Cocoa
1 teaspoon Cinnamon
Pinch Salt
Handful of walnuts, finely chopped (optional)

Chocolate Icing:

Icing sugar (enough to form a thin paste)
1 teaspoon butter, softened
1 tablespoon cocoa
Water

DIRECTIONS:

Preheat the oven to 180 degrees celsius (160 degrees fan-forced). Grease a 21cm round cake tin with non-stick spray.

Cream butter and sugar together until mixture is pale and creamy. Beat in the egg. Combine the flour, baking powder, bicarb soda and salt together. Slowly add the milk and flour mix at the same time while beating constantly on low-medium speed. Don’t worry if the batter appears a little curdled, it will bake beautifully.

Warm the golden syrup in the microwave for about 15 seconds so that it can be easily beaten into the batter. Pour 1/2 the mixture into a bowl and stir in the cinnamon and cocoa until well mixed. Pour the chocolate batter into the cake tin first, smooth the surface, then add the caramel layer. Smooth over the top with your spatula and bake for 45-55 minutes. Keep an eye on the cake in the first 10 minutes: if the edges have started to bake fast and the middle appears to sink, turn down the heat of your oven by around 10 degrees. The cake is ready if the top springs back when pressed, the centre doesn’t wobble and the sides of the cake have shrunk away from the edge of the tin. Allow to cool in the tin, then turn cake onto a wire rack to cool completely.

To let the flavour of this cake shine through, ice the cake with just a thin layer of a simple, traditional chocolate icing. Sprinkle finely chopped walnuts on top for a little crunch and texture.

Serve at your next ladies social meet along with a cup of tea.

Bookmark/Favorites
  • ooh i love an old skool recipe! golden syrup is so delish!

  • This looks so good! Golden syrup always reminds me of this yummy golden syrup pudding my nan used to make… it was so comforting and homey! I may have to add this to my “to do” list :)

  • Lovely! I love vintage recipes :) I need to get into Mad Men. Yes, the dresses! Gorgeous.
    Heidi xo

  • I love vintage recipes too! And Mad Men while I’m at it. Although I do recall seeing an interview with the Mad Men cast and someone mentioned that Betty never eats, only drinks and smokes! :P

  • A bit of vintage cake… YUM! caramel, chocolate… heavenly.

  • What I wouldn’t give for a half-hour free-for-all in the Mad Men wardrobe department… and I hefty slice of caramel-golden-syrup chocolate cak at the end. Oh, perfect imaginary afternoon! :D

  • Wow what a treat for special occasions! Looks so moist!

  • Wow looks divine and very indulgant and moorish. Drooling just thinking about it. Lovely flavour combo

  • I love unpretentious food and this cake looks gloriously moist and tasty. I’m definitely going to bake this one! Thanks for the recipe!

  • Yum! This is definitely a recipe to bookmark and bake soon. What a find!

  • Hi Nakahna, what a great find in the bookshop. My first attempt following the method exactly as written went terribly bad!!! The mixture split really grossly and the caramel layer sunk. But with some tweaking the magic of the recipe came through. Happy baking! Let us know how it goes.

  • Hi Nakahna, what a great find in the bookshop. My first attempt following the method exactly as written went terribly bad!!! The mixture split really grossly and the caramel layer sunk. But with some tweaking the magic of the recipe came through. Happy baking! Let us know how it goes.

  • Agree- golden syrup is just SO great. Really. Seriously great.

  • oh yummy this looks great!

  • I love those vintage recipes. They bring to memory happy childhood moments.

  • The cake looks absolutely divine. OMG caramel. Once of my many weaknesses. Old fashion recipes are always good to go back to. It seems to work every time.

  • sign me up for a big slice of that!!

  • Goopy goopiness all up in your face. Nice one :)

    Golden syrup really is hard to beat.

  • Great looking cake. I love golden syrup in cakes too

  • This is INDEED a scrumptious recipe! So glad to have found your precious website! Also try the carrot cake from the Nyamutin (Nigh-ah-mutt-an) Farm Cookbook.

    I am rather blessed to live at Nyamutin Farm in the south west of the Wheatbelt of Western Australia, and you will be glad to know that the darling Miss Bernice Shaddick is still alive! The rose garden where they took their tea is still in bloom. I will print off your page and take it to Bernice the next time I see her. She will say, “Well fancy that!” :)

  • Hi Geire,

    Thanks for your kind words. I must indeed try the carrot cake. That’s so amazing that you’re at Nyamutin and Miss Shaddick is still around. Please say hello, and thank you for me.
    I was talking to my Mum about the book and she said Bernice made her beautiful 4 tier wedding cake. Mum’s side of the family are from Pingelly, not too far away. The surname was Narducci back then :)

  • Looks awesome.

    The moisture is oozing out :)

    Matthew

  • At what point do you actually add the golden syrup and to which bowl? The bowl without the Cocoa and cinnamon?

  • Hi Bel,
    After you’ve beaten in the milk and flour you split the batter evenly into two bowls. In one bowl you stir in the chocolate and cinnamon and in the other you stir in the golden syrup.
    Happy Baking,
    The Cake Mistress

  • Pingback: Easter Eats | Food Bloggers : On Food Blogs and Food Blogging

  • Yummo! I just tried making this cause I was craving sweet but I got a bit confused at the different mixture parts. What’s the caramel layer? /o After adding the chocolatey golden syrup to the batter I had it kinda marbley and then I stuck that into the tray. Shouldn’t it just be batter? What layer am I missing? It’s still baking so hope it turns out alright >_>”

  • This looks very tempting even though I still have a chocolate cake in the freezer!

  • I have made this twice now… both times delicious. You are correct, you need to watch it during the cooking. The first time I covered the top with foil for the last 20mins as it began to burn. The caramel is very moist, the choc was noticeably less moist. Definitely a winner! Thanks for sharing :-)

  • My mum’s side of the family are from the Pingelly/Brookton area – the Cliffs. Mum has the Nyamutin cookbook and I’m always asking her to send more recipes from it to me!

  • Can you use maple syrup instead of golden syrup?

  • Hi Elle,
    At a guess, I’d say sure. Might just change the flavour. The golden syrup is really just there for the ‘caramel’ flavour, so hopefully it will still turn out the same.

    Happy baking!

  • Hi Mich,

    I’d only be guessing at how well it might turn out in a bundt tin. My first worry is the volume and shape difference: this one was baked in a 20cm round cake tin whereas bundt tins tend to be larger? So you might need to double the ingredients and use enough batter to fill the bundt 3/4 full. The size of the tin is going to impact the baking time unfortunately, so I can only suggest keeping a close eye on it after to 45 minute mark. It’s typically done with the top springs back when lightly pressed, there’s no obvious wobble to the batter and the sides start to shrink away slightly from the pan.

    Kind Regards,
    Emma
    The Cake Mistress

  • I made this cake for my boss’s birthday and I received a ton of compliments on it. My favorite was “This was the way cakes used to taste before oil was in everything.” I didn’t have any golden syrup so I used a mix of maple syrup and molasses (the internet told me that was a fine substitution). I made two cakes and layered them. My first cake used more molasses than maple so that part came out more golden. The second cake I used more maple so that part looked more off-white– the cake ended up three toned which added to the “wow” factor. I used a chocolate buttercream frosting and topped it with crushed walnuts.

Previous post:

Next post: